Thanks to the CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY @CenterForBioDiv and the Abrams Environmental Law Clinic @AbramsEnvtlClin at the University of Chicago for getting this done!
Important note: FISH has also informed INDOT, in writing and at the project’s public event in Bedford on February 19, that we oppose route alternative M for the Mid-States;
“Page 28 of your Screening of Alternatives Report, dated this month, lists five federally endangered mussel species which are associated with the East Fork White River in Lawrence and/or Martin counties. Endangered cavefish are also a concern in that region. Our biggest concern, however, is the last remaining population of the genetically-distinct lake sturgeon which historically ranged throughout the Ohio River drainage. These spectacular creatures now are known to survive only below Williams Dam in Lawrence County (which blocks their movement upstream), and downstream to some point in Martin County. Roughly 50 river miles or so. The State of Indiana does not provide a numerical estimate of this state-endangered fish’s population, which it has only described for some years as ‘small.’
Our organization, plus state and national allies including the Center for Biological Diversity, are currently seeking protection for that population of lake sturgeon under the Endangered Species Act, a process that formally began in May 2018. You’ll be hearing more about our actions very soon. FISH is also seeking the removal of Williams Dam in order to extend their range eastward and restore their population.
Therefore, FISH hereby states its opposition to alternative route M, which would run smack-through the lake sturgeon’s only habitat. Any segments of your project must steer well clear of that environmentally sensitive area.”
Center for Biological Diversity’s press release text:
Lawsuit Targets Trump Administration Delays in Protecting Ancient Lake Sturgeon
CHICAGO— Conservation groups sued the Trump administration today for delaying a determination of whether imperiled populations of lake sturgeon will be protected under the Endangered Species Act. Millions of lake sturgeon once lived in the Great Lakes and Mississippi Basin but today the population is less than 1 % of historic levels.
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service made an initial finding in 2019 that listing the lake sturgeon as threatened or endangered may be warranted. But the agency missed a May 2019 deadline for determining whether the giant, ancient fish actually warrants protection.
“These ancient survivors swam with dinosaurs 200 million years ago, but lake sturgeon need our help to survive climate change and damage to their river and lake habitats,” said Jeff Miller at the Center for Biological Diversity. “Every day the Trump administration delays a decision about protecting these fish is a day they move closer to extinction. In order to keep viable lake sturgeon populations we’ll need to remove key dams and allow sturgeon to repopulate more of their former river habitats.”
“We hope this will bring a swift resolution on Endangered Species Act protection so we can get to the critical and urgent work of restoring lake sturgeon in the Great Lakes and Mississippi River basin,” said Kim Knowles with Prairie Rivers Network.
“The lake sturgeon’s listing and accompanying recovery efforts are long overdue, and we look forward to this magnificent fish thriving once again in the Ohio River basin and Lake Michigan,” said Tim Maloney with the Hoosier Environmental Council.
The lake sturgeon is an ancient fish that lives primarily in the Great Lakes and the Mississippi River basin. Sturgeon can live up to 100 years, grow more than 8 feet long, and weigh nearly 300 pounds. The species’ numbers have declined more than 99% over the past century because of overfishing, dams and pollution. There are only nine large lake sturgeon populations in the United States that have more than 1,000 adult fish.
A May 2018 petition by the Center for Biological Diversity requested a “threatened” listing under the Endangered Species Act for all lake sturgeon in the United States, or alternatively separately listing distinct populations of lake sturgeon as threatened or endangered.
The Service missed the May 2019 deadline for a final determination on listing, but made a late initial finding in August 2019 that protecting the lake sturgeon may be warranted. The Service postulated that there may be distinct sturgeon populations in Lake Superior, western Lake Michigan, the upper Mississippi River basin and the Ohio River basin. The Service initiated a scientific status review, with a public comment period running through Dec. 31, 2020.
The Center for Biological Diversity, Fishable Indiana Streams for Hoosiers, Hoosier Environmental Council and Prairie Rivers Network jointly filed today’s lawsuit to speed the listing process. The organizations are represented by the Abrams Environmental Law Clinic at the University of Chicago Law School.
In the late 1800s, before commercial fisheries decimated lake sturgeon runs, more than 15 million lake sturgeon lived in the Great Lakes. They are now reduced to less than 1% of historic levels, with limited natural recovery of most remaining spawning populations.
Dams and hydroelectric facilities continue to harm lake sturgeon by blocking access to spawning habitat, fragmenting sturgeon populations and altering stream flows. Other threats to sturgeon include river dredging and channelization, habitat fragmentation, climate change and invasive species.
Many states and tribal organizations are working to restore sturgeon spawning populations. Most states within the fish’s range prohibit or limit harvest. Although many current restoration efforts are aimed at bringing lake sturgeon back to rivers and tributaries where they once spawned, depleted sturgeon populations take many decades to recover, and the vast majority of spawning runs have been lost.